As a person with bipolar, I can tell you, I did and I didn’t ask for help before my suicide attempt. I had been asking for mental health help, begging for help with bipolar disorder before my suicide attempt; however, I did not seek out suicide-specific help before my suicide attempt. And while we have data saying that many people see a doctor before attempting suicide, what we also know is that many people with bipolar disorder are not asking for help before a suicide attempt — even if they do see a doctor.
Seeing a Doctor But Not Asking for Suicide Attempt Help?
Several studies have reported that between 20% and 76% of patients who commit suicide have seen their primary care physician (many having seen mental health professionals specifically) in the prior month. In other words, people are seeing doctors and on some level really, really want help, but they just aren’t getting it.
In the case of those with bipolar disorder, there are so many reasons why they might not get help before a suicide attempt, even if they do see a doctor. Just off the top of my head:
- Those with bipolar are not taken seriously, possibly due to chronic suicidal ideation.
- The person with bipolar disorder is assumed to be exaggerating or even lying for attention.
- If the person has had previous suicide attempts that were not considered “serious,” it’s assumed any other suicide attempt also won’t be “serious.”
- The doctor doesn’t see what he or she considers the signs of serious suicidality.
- The doctor doesn’t even consider that the patient may be considering suicide.
- The doctor doesn’t have time to engage in a real discussion with the patient about suicide.
- The doctor doesn’t ask the right questions about suicide and the seriousness of the suicidal ideation.
- The person with bipolar doesn’t readily admit to having serious suicidal feelings.
There are so many reasons that any of the above might occur, and I think it’s important to realize that I’m not trying to place blame on the doctor or the person with bipolar. This situation has wound-together factors and is complicated. While doctors are the final gatekeeper in this scenario, they can’t, solely, be pointed to as the single-point-of-failure because, let’s face it, sometimes we’re to blame, too. If we lie about being suicidal, if we aren’t forthcoming, it’s almost impossible for someone else to help us. I wish someone could reach into the brains of those who are suicidal and help, but that’s just not the way it works. No one truly knows what you’re thinking about but you.
Bipolars Not Asking for Help Before a Suicide Attempt — Why?
As the above notes, many, many of us seek medical help before a suicide attempt and yet we don’t get it and I believe a lot of this is because we’re not being forthright about our suicidal ideation. We’re not saying we’re suicidal or we’re not saying how suicidal we truly are.
And I get this. I’ve been in this position. When I ended up hospitalizing myself for suicidal ideation, even though I had been seeing a psychiatrist, I didn’t make it clear to him how truly suicidal I was. That’s why I ended up in the Emergency Room one night sobbing for hours and being admitted that way.
While that may sound nutty, I can tell you that sitting in a room in front of a doctor and trying to relay how suicidal you are is extremely difficult. It seems impossible at times. I have seen people over and over talk about their suicidality on Facebook, for example, but not be able to talk to a healthcare professional about it. Telling, literally, the world on social media is easier than telling that one person staring at you in that tiny room.
Maybe it’s because telling that one person in that tiny room makes it real and means that action has to be taken. This plays into all our fears. It plays into our fears of scary mental hospitals, treatment without consent, forced electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) and not being allowed to leave, among others. These can be scary, scary things to play in your head. They can be brick walls between you and a doctor.
But I can honestly tell you that “action” being taken isn’t necessarily a bad thing. In fact, it’s likely exactly what you need. And the action being taken is rarely what you fear. For example, if you’re coming to a psychiatrist and saying that you’re acutely suicidal and need hospitalization, you’ll likely be checking yourself into the facility. You won’t be there against your will. You won’t be given treatment against your will. Certainly, no one is going to strap you to a bed and force ECT on you. This is just fear talking. That fear is real and should be listened to but it also should be talked back to.
There are other reasons you might be scared of admitting serious suicidality to a doctor too:
- You might not want to “let the doctor down” by admitting that you’re so sick.
- You might be worried about being judged by the doctor.
- You might be worried about any additional ramifications this may have — your family finding out, your work finding out, missing work, etc.
- You might be scared the healthcare professional won’t listen to you or believe you.
- You might be scared the doctor won’t help you no matter what.
Of course, this is all assuming you still have enough of your faculties to think clearly and rationally and posess insight. Unfortunately, this isn’t always true. But I might argue that if you don’t have your faculties enough to think through the situation and you’re on the brink of killing yourself, you likely need hospitalization no matter what — to save your life.
If You Have Bipolar and Are Considering Suicide
You know what I’m going to say now, don’t you? I’m going to say this:
If you’re feeling suicidal, you need to talk to a professional as soon as possible, no matter what. Walk into an Emergency Room or call 9-1-1 if you have to.
You need to talk back to your fear. You need to stand up to your fear. You need to know that doctors are there to help. I know that sounds trite, but it’s true. And you need to know that if you run into a bad doctor who doesn’t believe you or who doesn’t help you, you need to keep talking to professionals until you get the help you need and deserve. Remember, your life is important and fragile and you need to treat it as such.
I understand why a person with bipolar disorder may not ask for help before a suicide attempt. I get it because I’ve been there. But I don’t want anyone else to be there. I want you to know that things can get better and you can get the help you need without taking that final, drastic step. Believe me, doctors really do want to help you. I know you can run into bad ones and I’m sorry for that, but overall, these people are in a helping profession and that is what they want to do. Get suicide attempt help with their aid or without it, just get it because you matter. Your life matters. I want you to be here to see your best tomorrow.
See here for a list of helpful suicide attempt phone numbers and websites.
The one time that I was SERIOUSLY suicidal and actually made the decision that I was going to kill myself, I told no one. The reason for not telling anyone was simple: I truly wanted to kill myself, and telling someone would have meant that they’d take efforts to stop me.
What stopped your plan?
Very insightful article. Personally I have asked for help before a suicide attempt, received help, and was ok. I have asked for help, received help, and still made an attempt on my life. That long dark road we have all gone down is different and filled with different obstacles for everyone, but it ends at the same place. To me the answer is to continue to do away with the negativity and ignorance that most people still have regarding our mental illness. If we felt we could talk we would!
I can answer without all the bloviating and mental health industry propaganda:
I don’t do it because the help doesn’t work, and the doctors don’t really care. Life just isn’t worth putting up with.
Great and real article discussing the struggle of getting help for bipolar and suicidal thoughts. Even though I’m not bipolar, I’ve suffered through a lot of these issues when contemplating suicide or struggling with suicidal ideations in the past. Hopefully this brings more awareness and can help more people.
I can understand how difficult it is to live with a family that is not talking to you, afterall Family matters alot. :-)
Very good post. One of the Samaritan websites said suicidal ideation is just being overwhelmed with stress and problems and not having enough coping skills or support to deal with it. There is a picture of a see saw of a person with a lot of stress on one side. On the other side, a lot of support, weight/counterweights and coping skills help to keep the see saw in balance in the picture. I’ve found this too be true. When the issues are bad, taking a walk and listening to music doesn’t alleviate the stress. Talking to people can, but doing an activity with someone who cares and talking through the issues with them makes a difference. Of course, it can take a while for the real bad thoughts and symptoms to go away. Self care and support is important!
Bipolar people feel deeply and sometimes need more time and space to work through their emotions. I have BP and am this way.
Peace to all. Good post and a lot of good insight here.
Why? I’ll tell you why. Because no one in my family gives a shit. I recently returned from my daughter’s Navy graduation. I was sitting peacefully at home thinking about how well everything had gone when my sister, who hadn’t talked to me in 3 months, called. Her job was to flaunt knowledge of the graduation in my face. Apparently my daughter had gone to lunch with my 2 sisters (neither one of them are speaking to me) before leaving for boot camp without telling me. 38 years of successfully living with bipolar, one planned suicide, and no one in my family is talking to me including my mother. Why bother? I die, they get what they want and I’m out of this excruciating pain.
Hi Sue,
I can understand how difficult it is to live with a family that isn’t talking to you. While members of my family are talking to me, one member is not and it’s very hard.
But I have to say, we choose our own families once be become an adult. You have a daughter. She is your family. You were at her graduation. Clearly, she wanted you there and that is something very special.
But on top of that, you have the friends and loved ones you have met and have chosen to have relationships met. Your death isn’t what they deserve even if you feel like your family does. You touch more people than you understand and your death would too. I know it may not seem that way, but believe me, it is.
– Natasha Tracy
The staff in the ER are the worst, and the Emergency Psych ward is not safe where I live as there are many amphetamine addicts going through psychosis coming through the doors and there are not enough rooms to keep other patients and staff safe. It’s gone as far as half of the dept quitting and the local teaching uni pulling out their residents.
The gov’t keeps cutting money to fund access to services more and more (I live in Canada), cutting funding for hospitals and mental health centers, etc. I live in one of the worst cities for hate crimes in Canada and as a disabled LGBT member who has recently been harassed and beat up for attempting to use public facilities and then getting attacked again at a PRIDE parade where the cops did nothing… and then seeing the same cops go on social media disparaging the marginalized groups… the mayor doesn’t even bother with his constituents and protect the police… I’m having it constantly reinforced that people like myself don’t matter, don’t belong, and aren’t wanted in society.
I’m tired. In Pain. I’m using public services and have had a new therapist and new psychiatrist within the last year. This new psychiatrist only takes UP TO 15 mins with patients. Not nearly enough time to even go over my history even if I give a TL;DR version… despite him having a binder worth of notes about me from my last psych he can read over at any time.
I haven’t slept more than 3 hrs a night for 2 months, if I do its nightmares/terrors. I’m not trying to take Xanax daily just to get an hour of “rest” only to become addicted… I am honest with my therapist. She knows how bad I am. Not sleeping. Extremely agitated mentally and physically. Haven’t left my place in over 2 months since I got attacked, when I do people harass me- let alone all the micro aggression I come to face (not in my head- they are REAL! not just paranoid!) But in the last session, she didn’t bother asking if I was suicidal despite literally saying stuff like “I can’t do this anymore. I just want to sleep… never wake up again”. I was so agitated I ended up quitting therapy because whats the point?
But then again even if she asked me I would lie because I’ve only ever had horrible experiences at the hospital and I’m not interested in repeating it. I honestly would rather just die than go through all that and get re traumatized again while being gaslighted, invalidated, and coerced into taking medication that causes me severe side effects like losing my voice for years… but hey its worth putting me on Seroquel… who cares if I don’t have a voice anymore. It would probably be preferred by everyone to stay that way I bet. If thats the case just let me fucking go die in a corner by myself instead.
I think some people don’t tell they are really suicidal because here, they call the police and they take you in cuffs to the hospital.
Because we’re not attention-seeking fakers. When we wanna die we really wanna die
I get what you’re saying, Hunter. When I am suicidal it means I’ve decided that I’m better off not being here, *and that everyone else will be better off too*. Telling another person how I feel at such times is as embarrassing as telling a strange lady doctor in Emergency that I have a painful growth on my penis. Admitting to feeling suicidal implies I really *don’t* want to die. As I write this, I’m in hospital because I told my psychiatrist I could not promise to “stay safe” as she calls it.
Truthfully, I did *not* want to die, I just wanted the emotional pain to end. That’s not exactly the same as actually wanting to die, in my humble opinion. I can’t honestly claim I would tell my psychiatrist if I seriously planned to kill myself. I would probably consider it cruel to put her in a position where she had to track me down and stop me. I hope it won’t happen, but if I ever firmly decide to die in the future, I doubt if I’ll tell anyone.
Hi Hunter,
I think what you’re talking about it people who attempt suicide but don’t want to die: https://natashatracy.com/bipolar-disorder/attempt-suicide-not-die/ (Read the article to know what I mean.) This does not make them attention-seeking fakers. This makes them very sick people in need of help immediately.
But regardless as to whether you consciously think you want to die or not, what I think is true is that people _don’t_want_to_die_ they just want the pain to end and they see suicide as the only way. This isn’t about being a “faker” or an “attention-seeker” either. This, again, is about needing very serious help immediately.
I can understand what you’re saying — I really can, but only a small percentage of suicide attempts made by people with bipolar disorder end in death. We want to live as much as anyone else.
– Natasha Tracy