I Want to Attempt Suicide but Not Die
OK, I understand that a suicide attempt is not a suicide attempt if the end desire is not death, but stick with me here, I have a point.
Believe it or not, I get a lot of searches on this site by people searching for ways to attempt suicide and not die (their words). And while many people may find this unbelievable, I don’t actually think it’s all that uncommon. I think many people make suicide attempts that are less about death and more about screaming for help.
The World of Treating a Mental Illness
In a perfect world, as soon as a person saw the symptoms of a mental illness, he would see a doctor, who would refer him to a psychiatrist for an accurate diagnosis and effective treatment. In a perfect world, this would all happen very quickly and the patient would go from crazy to sane in a matter of weeks. In a perfect world, that treatment would work forever and the person with the mental illness would lead a happy life and never look back.
Does anyone think we live in a perfect world?
No. Instead we live in a world where people ignore their mental illness symptoms for months, or even years, get incorrect diagnoses and ineffectual help. This is no one’s fault, necessarily, it’s just that even when everyone does the very best they can, not everyone gets better in a timely fashion. Moreover, when treatment does work, it doesn’t mean that it will last forever. No, more likely there will be episodes of mental illness in the future requiring new or augmented treatment that may take months to be resolved.
Desperation Leads to Suicide Attempts
And the problem lies in the group of people who aren’t being successfully treated. For whatever reason, these people with mental illness are being treated but the treatment just isn’t effective.

And when this happens, I can attest from experience, you would beg anyone and everyone for help if you thought it would lead to effective treatment. You become beyond desperate.
It feels like you’re screaming and crying and praying and sobbing and wailing no one is paying attention. It feels like no matter what you tell your doctor they don’t “get it” because they just aren’t helping you.
And again, in most cases it’s not that the doctors aren’t trying, it’s just that they’re failing.
But it doesn’t feel like that. It feels like no one is listening to you. It feels like no one is taking you seriously. It feels like if only they understood how much pain I’m in, they would help me.
And so you want to make them understand your pain. You want to make them take you seriously. You want to attempt suicide. I suspect nothing gets people’s attention quite like thinking you’re about to die.
When is a Suicide Attempt not a Suicide Attempt?
And these suicide attempts are fundamentally the same as any other suicide attempt – the people committing them really do want to end their suffering and they really are risking their own lives. These suicide attempts mean the same thing: Help me; I’m in pain and I don’t know how to get out of it.
And don’t mistake this type of suicide attempt for some kind of manipulation either. It’s not. It’s just trying to up the amperage on a scream so that someone will help you out of the pain that is trying to kill you. Because you don’t want to die. You just want the pain to stop.
Attempting Suicide Won’t Help You
But the trouble is if you were in your right mind, you would probably realize that a suicide attempt would not help your cause. This is because the doctors are likely doing all they can already and you spending time in an emergency room isn’t going to change what they are able to do. In fact, it may lessen the chances that a doctor will be able to help you due to whatever injuries you sustain (like to your kidneys and liver) when you attempt suicide.
So don’t do it. Don’t attempt suicide in a bid to get help. It’s not going to work.
What to Do Instead of Attempting Suicide
Instead of planning a suicide attempt that you hope won’t work, try getting help that might. For example, tell your doctor that you’re thinking of attempting suicide. Many people don’t do this for fear they will be “locked up” but what do you think is going to happen if you actually do attempt suicide? Talking about suicide is infinitely better than actually doing it. Tell your doctor about the desperation you are feeling. Tell your doctor what you feel that desperation is leading you to. Make it very clear that you need your disorder to be taken as seriously as a goddamned heart attack. Maybe that means new meds. Maybe that means referral to another doctor. Maybe that means considering other options. Whatever it means, it means something and it means something now.
[push]A suicide attempt isn’t going to get you what you want.[/push]
And then you will just have to accept that help takes time. Your treatment isn’t going to be instantaneous. You likely aren’t going to wake up tomorrow pain-free. That pain that you’re in is likely to hang around for quite some time. You have to wait it out. It’s not pleasant, it’s not what you want to hear, but it’s the truth.
So I absolutely understand the desperation that would lead you to a suicide attempt. I absolutely understand why you would want to be on death’s door. I absolutely understand why you feel like people aren’t taking you seriously.
But a suicide attempt isn’t going to get you what you want. Instead, keep going to real people who can really help you. And if you can’t do that, then admit yourself to a hospital instead of attempting suicide. Because the damage of an attempted suicide is going to make your pain worse, not better.
(Suicide and suicide attempt resources found here.)

Kate O'Brien - April 6, 2013 ←
Hi Natasha, this is fantastic post and it really addresses the problem of a cry for help. Having read this I am going to change my ways and get the help I need, whatever it takes. You have given me hope. Thank you.
Susan - February 24, 2013 ←
Love this site, I want it for myself only. I think it is important to say something about suicide and hope others will agree with me. I personally have attempted suicide with the full intention of dying. I had tried twice before and was unsuccessful. The third time was my time to go and be gone from this torture. I was very sad to wake up and find myself alive. I was very angry that someone found me collapsed in my own bed and called an ambulance. When I woke up I was shocked! Why couldn’t they leave me alone. I was again misdiagnosed and sent back to an abusive family with no meds and no help. So I faked being happy until I left home as an adult. Now, I’m a depressed, divorced mother of one who hates herself still. My child is married and I’m still living a depressed life and want to finally end it again. I’m on meds but I can fake being well too. Presently told doctor I was a fake and can’t get out of bed. Was not taken seriously and now the only, the ONLY thing that’s holding me here are my dogs. The youngest is 8 yrs old and I’m waiting for him to die so I can go too. My original note for here was to inform others that suicide should not be only understood to be a cry for help, but a real concrete decision to be found dead. That is it.
Susan - February 24, 2013 ←
(Hey, we have the same name!)… Anyway, Susan, I know how you feel. I’m sorry that you really want to die. I have recently figured out that for me, this intense desire for suicide is really a desire to escape, not to die. I have been satisfying that escape desire in different plans and ideas of how to escape my life and/or this world as it is. No, it’s probably not the healthiest thing in the world, but those fantasies fulfill that need to escape and allow me to feel more comfortable having to stay here. (((hugs)))
Susan - February 24, 2013 ←
Thanks Susan for the encouragement, but at my age death is not scary anymore. Fantasies are worn out and I’ve closed the doors to any dreams. I am so glad I found this site, so many write the same feelings so well. I not only stumble around I fumble in my words in trying to say what I feel. So I’ve stopped talking until now, right here. A connection? I don’t know, I’m too tired to care and solve any more issues I’ve had all my life. Thanks anyways.
Kate - January 25, 2013 ←
I just wanted to say that your post has pretty much summed up how I felt the last few months. But finally I think someone is listening and going me the help that I need. Thanks. :)
kay kay - January 21, 2013 ←
I do not want to live I have failure in all my efforts suggest me what to do
Sarah - January 22, 2013 ←
Keep trying! You will eventually succeed.
Denise - February 6, 2013 ←
I tried to kill myself December 21 and luckily I didn’t die though sometimes I think it would have been easier. You need help! You can get help but you have to get it. Only you can rescue yourself. There is no knight in shining armor. I am on medication but its a lot of work to just be normal and I struggle everyday. Please go the doctor I care what happens you and I am putting my arms around you and holding you close.
Susan - February 24, 2013 ←
All any of us can do, kay kay, is just keep trying to hang on!
Laura - January 10, 2013 ←
Your post reminded me of those time when being in such pain all I wanted was for it to stop. There were times when not wanting to die wasn’t the goal, but most of the time it has been the goal to not actually die. I also realized reading your post that I was dealing with SI for so long but I was not getting proper help (I am now). Telling everyone I was suicidal got me treatment, but I don’t think the right help. From personal experience not wanting to die but wanting to attempt is in itself a way I cope with that excruciating emotional pain. While I’m focusing on what I could do to self harm or I’m planning a suicide I’m not feeling the pain so much. It’s a way to relieve the pain temporarily by imagining not having it or getting to a place where I will not have it. This insight came after decades of spending long periods of time where suicidal ideation consumed me, finding out I really could do something different about the pain and not be taken for the ride. Today I know my response to specific emotional triggers is a rapid shift to my baseline – ideation. Shifting has gone way down with this awareness and handling the emotional triggers better and better. It also takes all the wind out of it. I don’t have the fear that I may go through with anything. And the fear that I’m actually doing it again. This is not to say I still have to work my butt off at times to keep it at bay, but it is easier to deal and it leaves fast. Wanting out of emotional pain with its desperation and hopelessness is why our brain/mind goes to SI. Thanks!
Sara - January 8, 2013 ←
nothing gets people’s attention quite like thinking you’re about to die.
Theirin is the heart of the matter. If only people could understand that the pin is as bad as it is. And that people can’t take the pain anymore. And that many people DO die when they cannot take the pain anymore–even if what they truly desire is not death at all; but or the pain to stop.
April - January 8, 2013 ←
You forgot to mention that when a person does finally get a doctor’s appointment, the medicine that is prescribed usually takes at least 6 weeks to feel any effects. That time seems so much longer, because the person has made an attempt to make things better, and now, it’s just another waiting game. THEN, if that medicine doesn’t work, try a new one, and wait 6 more weeks. That waiting game was when I didn’t want to live anymore.
Judie - January 8, 2013 ←
April!!!! you are soooo right !! i never thought of that here in the blog about this………people wanting & needing help cannot be just sent back home with their meds whether after a suicide attempt or diagnosis etc.They need a helping hand to climb out of their darkness & confusion …”in the meantime waiting six weeks” ….the specialist &/or doctor need to help patient get supports in place to help them when they walk out that door….especially if really down & if never been on meds before, etc. It’s no wonder why so many people fall back in their mental illness, addiction etc. & end up back in the hospital or consider attempting suicide, when left to their own devices……..of course, i am not saying they need to be babysat, however, depending on circumstances the appropriate questions need to asked of patient by medical professionals to make sure the patient will be ok for the next 6 weeks….maybe even for the next few days…ie a phone call or daily checkin from patient or even a brief stay in hospital….just to get monitored closely again depending on situation/circumstances. Everyone is different. In my experience i was prescribed an antidepressant in 2001 & it didn’t sink in that drinking with it was a big deal….April 2003….i attempted suicide ending up in hospital !!! The doctor prescribed me meds….no referral to a specialist at the time…no follow-ups how i was doing, or cautioning me to not drink with them………..what i remember looking back it was like “here you go, this should help you”! period. I didn’t know what was wrong with me, i didn’t know anything about antidepressant ..i was pretty ignorant about it all back then. However, even coming out of hospital two weeks later I still went on drinking with my meds………….but…….by the grace of God, my higher power somehow led me to get sober somehow…..June 26, 2003…i have been sober ever since, (very lucky thing as , none of this would have had given me a clear understanding of what healthy choices i needed to make ) & also I was soooo close to losing my job & everything else that could have come with that before April 2003 when things were so bad….instead with being sober i tried going back to work but finally realized i needed to quit & here i am on Long Term Disability & pension, so i could focus on getting better! So at least even tho i am still struggling to get the help i need, in last couple years i feel i have so many symptoms of bipolar on top of Major Depression & feel i have symptoms of ADHD mixed into the equasion, but i do feel i am moving forward … one day at a time, hoping & believing i can get the help….as i keep putting my foot down hard & demand some help now when things start getting unclear & overwhelming etc.!
Judie
Susan - January 8, 2013 ←
Wow, Natasha, have you been in my head during the last week? I’m just coming off a mixed state that spiraled into huge, frantic SI. Desperately screaming for help (on the inside) while not reaching out to anybody. Not wanting to go to the hospital because they’ll just mess with my meds. I can get babysat at home without the drama or medicine confusion that results from hospitalization… if only I’d ask for help.
Your blog posts are wonderful. Please keep writing.
Thankfully, it seems to be fading. This time… The *fantastic* thing about bipolar is that it WILL return. Maybe next time I can ask for help instead of researching methods.
Kelly - January 8, 2013 ←
Hi. Not sure where I’ve been, but I just found your work over the last several days. I was diagnosed with having Bipolar 1 fourteen years ago. I have had on and off struggles and recently hit a new low. I want to thank you for sharing so much information through all you write. Reading many of your blogs over the last few days has kept me taking it a step at a time. I will be talking with my therapist and my dr this week. I truly appreciate you! Take care.
Kelly
Atlanta, GA
Susan - January 8, 2013 ←
Wow, Natasha, have you been in my head for the last week? Definitely screaming for help (inside) and not reaching out. Don’t want to go to the hospital because they just mess with my meds – I can get babysat by myself without the drama and the resulting med confusion… if only I asked for it instead of researching methods.
Thankfully, things seem to be improving for me. This time…
Judie - January 8, 2013 ←
Hi Natasha!!!
I so LOVE YOU & YOUR BLOGS & ALL THAT YOU WRITE ABOUT…i even have your posts coming to my inbox……..& am grateful for this one TODAY!!!
I felt like you were TALKING ABOUT ME!!! Wow to have had YOUR WORDS here for me to read 12 /13 years ago it may have helped me in 2003 when everything fell apart …….then again….who knows right?? oh the “what ifs???” …knowing me tho i know i would probably have taken your advice when STUFF started falling apart for me ….mentally & emotionally ! I could go on but…2 of the most important things you write about here for me was: It definitely was a HUGE SCREAM FOR HELP, because you don’t know what else to do & it is NOT MANIPULATION..!!
I believe some of my family & extended family thought that’s what it was…..however, they didn’t understand my past & how it was contributing to my ever increasing life falling apart………& i didnt’ know why exactly…..all i know is i was getting worse day by day week by week, month by month……..
This post i need to keep for myself….to remind myself why everything happened the way it did & that I was not CRAZY, OR WEAK…& ultimately help me keep hope getting more help that i am STILL needing. I haven’t been monitored for my symptoms of my mental health & over the last couple years i was going downhill again……..so i did exactly what you said January 2011 i got more insistent with my doctor, & it did get me some help but didn’t last so i started to fall apart again in 2012 (especially with my mom passing away suddenly) & i have finally found hope thru my health centre since they finally have been able to afford to bring two PSYCHIATRISTS on board………& i found out about something else for help thru my therapist (who i have only been able to findthis past summer, since my previous therapist moved away….i was without one for over two years). My therapist’s encouragement has been really godsend, giving back to me BELIEF IN MYSELF & BEING HOPEFUL AGAIN….so,
TODAY I am feeling pretty good (albeit i think hiding the ‘REAL’ sad, depressed, confused & frustrated ‘ME’ under a mask!!)
However, like i said i feel hopeful today, without ANY suicidal ideation over the few weeks…with is pretty hopeful i’d say, considering it was thru the holidays!!
Thanks you so much Natasha…….i found you on here over a year ago & read as many of your blogs as i can & i share on facebook & even get in to discussing it with others too…….I hope in the near future i get back to volunteering my time to mental health at my health centre like i was (5 years….had to pull back as my symptoms became worse, especially my depression). I hope to keep volunteering in the mental health sector to help others & see where it takes me to get back on my own to feet with more good self-esteem & confidence to do more & mroe.
Again thanks for all you do …
Judie
Ontario,Canada
Mary - January 7, 2013 ←
Really great post.